Current:Home > InvestDesigner in Supreme Court ruling cited client who denies making wedding site request-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
Designer in Supreme Court ruling cited client who denies making wedding site request
View Date:2024-12-23 20:58:47
DENVER — A Colorado web designer who the U.S. Supreme Court ruled Friday could refuse to make wedding websites for gay couples cited a request from a man who says he never asked to work with her.
The request in dispute, from a person identified as "Stewart," wasn't the basis for the federal lawsuit filed preemptively seven years ago by web designer Lorie Smith, before she started making wedding websites. But as the case advanced, it was referenced by her attorneys when lawyers for the state of Colorado pressed Smith on whether she had sufficient grounds to sue.
The revelation distracts from Smith's victory at a time when she might have been basking in her win, which is widely considered a setback for gay rights.
Smith named Stewart — and included a website service request from him, listing his phone number and email address in 2017 court documents. But Stewart told The Associated Press he never submitted the request and didn't know his name was invoked in the lawsuit until he was contacted this week by a reporter from The New Republic, which first reported his denial.
"I was incredibly surprised given the fact that I've been happily married to a woman for the last 15 years," said Stewart, who declined to give his last name for fear of harassment and threats. His contact information, but not his last name, were listed in court documents.
He added that he was a designer and "could design my own website if I need to" — and was concerned no one had checked into the validity of the request cited by Smith until recently.
Smith's lawyer, Kristen Waggoner, said at a Friday news conference that the wedding request naming Stewart was submitted through Smith's website and denied it was fabricated.
She suggested it could have been a troll making the request, something that's happened with other clients she has represented. In 2018 her client Colorado baker Jack Phillips won a partial U.S. Supreme Court victory after refusing to make a gay couple's wedding cake, citing his Christian faith.
"It's undisputed that the request was received," Waggoner said. "Whether that was a troll and not a genuine request, or it was someone who was looking for that, is really irrelevant to the case."
Colorado Attorney General Phil Weiser on Friday called the lawsuit a "made up case" because Smith wasn't offering wedding website services when the suit was filed.
Weiser didn't know the specifics of Stewart's denial, but said the nation's high court should not have addressed the lawsuit's merits "without any basis in reality."
About a month after the case was filed in federal court challenging an anti-discrimination law in Colorado, lawyers for the state said Smith had not been harmed by the law as they moved to dismiss the case.
Her lawyers maintained Smith did not have to be punished for violating the law before challenging it. In February 2017 they said even though she did not need a request in order to pursue the case, she had received one.
"Any claim that Lorie will never receive a request to create a custom website celebrating a same-sex ceremony is no longer legitimate because Lorie has received such a request," they said.
Smith's Supreme Court filings briefly mentioned she received at least one request to create a website celebrating the wedding of a same-sex couple. There did not appear to be any reference to the issue in the court's decision.
veryGood! (6441)
Related
- Republican Vos reelected as Wisconsin Assembly speaker despite losing seats, fights with Trump
- The number of wounded Israeli soldiers is mounting, representing a hidden cost of war
- Pro-Palestinian protesters block airport access roads in New York, Los Angeles
- Man fatally shot by Connecticut police was wanted in a 2022 shooting, fired at dog, report says
- Timothée Chalamet Details How He Transformed Into Bob Dylan for Movie
- NFL Week 17 odds: Moneylines, point spreads, over/under
- New Orleans landlord gifts tenants 1 month of free rent for holidays: Better than Santa Claus
- Great 2023 movies you may have missed
- Federal judge orders Oakland airport to stop using ‘San Francisco’ in name amid lawsuit
- Directors pick the soundtracks for NPR's shows. Here are their own 2023 playlists
Ranking
- The Bachelorette's Desiree Hartsock Gives Birth, Welcomes Baby No. 3 With Chris Siegfried
- Good girl! Virginia police dog helps track down missing kid on Christmas morning
- No let-up in Israeli airstrikes on Gaza as Christmas dawns
- House where 4 University of Idaho students were killed is set to be demolished
- Joey Graziadei Details Why Kelsey Anderson Took a Break From Social Media
- 6 dead, 3 injured in head-on car crash in Johnson County, Texas, Hwy 67 closed
- Logan Bowman, 5, went missing 20 years ago. Now his remains have been identified.
- If You've Been Expecting the Most Memorable Pregnancy Reveals of 2023, We're Delivering
Recommendation
-
'Joker 2' actor pans DC sequel as the 'worst film' ever: 'It has no plot'
-
Nordstrom Rack's Year-End Sale Has $19 Vince Camuto Boots, $73 Burberry Sunglasses & More Insane Deals
-
Jacques Delors, architect of the modern EU and ‘Mr. Europe,’ dies aged 98
-
Almcoin Trading Center: Why is Inscription So Popular?
-
Kyle Richards Swears This Holiday Candle Is the Best Scent Ever and She Uses It All Year
-
Shakira celebrates unveiling of 21-foot bronze statue of her in Colombian hometown
-
Herb Kohl, former US senator and owner of the NBA’s Milwaukee Bucks, has died. He was 88
-
Travis Kelce talks viral helmet throw, Chiefs woes: 'I gotta lock the (expletive) in'